Converting on Facebook: Why Losing Like-Gate Doesn’t Really Matter

Posted by Tim Ash on 1 September 2014 | Comments


Marketers must remain user-centric in order to earn conversions on Facebook. Posts that generate the most interaction and engagement will be the ones that see the highest reach.

losing like gateSocial media marketers have been buzzing about the recent change to Facebook's policies banning the practice of "fan-gating." Fan-gating (also more accurately called like-gating) is a common practice used to generate new likes by offering people an incentive for "liking" the page. The incentive might be a discount coupon or valuable content that could only be seen by people after they liked the page. And for lots of companies, the practice was effective.

But few conversion optimization experts would agree that accumulating new page likes is a true conversion metric. Not surprisingly, many marketers have found that the audiences they've built with this practice don't engage with the page after receiving the offer. Making matters worse, Facebook has been reducing the organic reach of Pages, making the number of likes even less effective to marketers. According to a recent study reported in Time magazine, "Even if a person Likes a company ... they're unlikely to naturally see that Page's content in their News Feed."

But this doesn't mean that Facebook has lost its effectiveness as a marketing and conversion tool. Instead, it's a reminder to marketers that remaining user-centric is still one of the best ways to earn the conversion. With the evolving Facebook algorithms, it's clear that the posts that generate the most interaction and engagement are the ones that will see the highest reach.

Facebook Conversions Rely on Interaction

Since you can't control how Facebook manages their algorithms, you need to concentrate on finding the best content mix for your page to engage your fans and drive your conversion rate. As is true for all social media platforms, interactions are the key to driving conversions.

According to a study by the University of Singapore, working with data from more than 14,000 clients of a fashion-industry company, researchers combined purchase data with advanced text-mining tools to determine the emotional tone of text-based interactions and their resulting conversions.

From this data, they concluded:

  • Conversions are impacted more strongly by user-generated content than marketer-generated content
  • Both positive and negative user-generated interactions increased sales if they contained detailed information
  • Direct marketer-generated content had a measurable effect on driving purchases, indirect did not
  • User-generated content was influential via indirect interactions more than direct interactions
  • Direct user-generated content such as reviews transformed products into inelastic commodities, making buyers less sensitive to price
  • Users who liked the Facebook page previous to a purchase had a $22 higher lifetime value over customers who didn't (due to social interactions)

What the study shows is that marketer activity on Facebook should have a single purpose: to generate meaningful and detailed user interactions. If a piece of content is shared but doesn't generate interactions, it is not driving conversions. Content that compels people to interact by answering a question, posting an opinion or sharing a comment is what will lead to conversion.

Improving Social Interaction Rate

Marketers are great at creating content calendars, but it can be more of a challenge to create social content that actually encourages interaction. Shopify suggests that posting surveys or asking questions is a good way to get started. Afraid of what people might say? Research shows you shouldn't be. In fact, both positive and negative customer opinions can improve conversions.

Here are some other tips for increasing engagement and social interaction:

  • Share content that your customers or partners have created
  • Congratulate (and tag) a customer on a success story
  • Add links to your blog posts as you publish them
  • Post your YouTube videos to your Facebook page
  • Embed your SlideShare presentations on your page
  • Upload photos from company events, cool new products, even staff. Never use stock photos!
  • Get creative with images and use them to showcase testimonials, a brief piece of advice, or other shareable message

People come to Facebook to build and maintain personal connections, so the more personal you can make your posts, videos, and photos, the more likely they are to inspire engagement.

Engagements, Not Likes, Lead to Conversions

Once you've figured out what content drives the most engagement with your visitors, you can start really optimizing your Facebook messaging strategy. Take a look not just at which posts get comments and shares, but also which ones generate click-throughs. Use these clicks to their fullest potential. If you're linking to a YouTube video, make sure you have an appropriate call to action embedded in the video and description. Likewise for blog posts and SlideShare presentations. Think about the click-path of every post and optimize every step along the way.

Ultimately, improving your Facebook conversion rate isn't up to Facebook and its algorithm. It is wholly dependent on your ability to create content that your customers and prospects want to read, find useful, and are inspired to share. It's about the user experience, not about your marketing and content calendars. Optimize for the user, and the conversions will follow.


This article originally appeared in Tim's ClickZ column August 22, 2014

'Want to optimize your conversion funnel but don't know where to start? Find out how we can help you with conversion rate optimization

Sites generating more than $5 million
Sites generating less than $5 million

Recent Blog Posts:

Google Analytics Segmentation Hacks Webinar with Dave Booth

Posted by SiteTuners on 29 August 2014 | Comments

Over 10 million web sites use Google Analytics.

comments | Read the full post

The State of Mobile: 4 Ways to Increase Conversions on Phones

Posted by SiteTuners on 28 August 2014 | Comments

Mobile is where the consumers are. So that’s where marketers need to be.

comments | Read the full post

What Visitors Want: 13 Tools for Collecting Feedback on Your Site

Posted by Tim Ash on 22 August 2014 | Comments

One of the best ways to discover how you can better your website is by asking your visitors what they want to see. Here are several tools that allow you to gather feedback from your visitors easily and effectively.

comments | Read the full post

Is CRO the Biggest Failure on the Web?

Posted by SiteTuners on 20 August 2014 | Comments

In an episode of Sales Lead Management (SLM) Radio, host Jim Obermayer picked SiteTuners CEO Tim Ash’s brain on the different chapters of the book Landing Page Optimization. Tim talked about why you should be focusing on conversion rate optimization (CRO) instead of driving traffic to your site. 

comments | Read the full post

Local Optimization Drives Conversions, But Your Local Page Won’t

Posted by Tim Ash on 15 August 2014 | Comments

When people in the online marketing community talk about the mobile shift, they usually do so in the context of one of these three things:

comments | Read the full post

FREE Webinar: Unlocking Mobile Conversions with Charles Nicholls

Posted by SiteTuners on 13 August 2014 | Comments

It is becoming more and more imperative for marketers to understand how users behave on mobile. It is expected that 83 percent of internet usage will be done on mobile by 2015. SeeWhy shared facts about mobile device usage that digital marketers need to Unlock Mobile Conversions.

comments | Read the full post

Balancing Optimization and Web Development

Posted by SiteTuners on 11 August 2014 | Comments

Kevin Eichelberger, founder and CEO of Blue Acorn, says that optimization is not given enough weight in design and development. He notes that in many companies today, optimization is done after the fact, when ideally, optimization techniques should be incorporated throughout the decision-making process.

comments | Read the full post

Tim Ash to Keynote the Integrated Marketing Virtual Conference

Posted by SiteTuners on 4 August 2014 | Comments

Despite the dizzying pace of advances for the technology-laden side of marketing - from marketing automation to multi-device tracking, from basic clickstream tracking to personalized conversion-centered campaigns, one thing anchors our efforts as marketers - the brain.

comments | Read the full post

3 Reasons You Should Be Collecting E-mail Addresses

Posted by SiteTuners on 2 August 2014 | Comments

Jeremy Schoemaker, founder and CEO of the ShoeMoney Blog, relates that several years ago, when somebody told him that he needed an e-mail list, he thought he was too good for it. Now looking back, he thinks his notion of being too good for an e-mail list was the dumbest...

comments | Read the full post

Copyright © 2004-2014. All Rights Reserved. Facebook Linkedin twitter Find us on Google+ contact us